Dustin MaySTL · MIL · SP

2026 review

Dustin May was a swing-and-miss arm who gave up hard contact and shuffled teams mid-year: he went 7-9 with a 4.70 ERA and 1.32 WHIP in 145.2 IP across 31 starts, striking out 144 with 50 BB, a 23.2 K% and an 8.1 BB% over 621 BF, moving from STL to MIL between his last game for STL Jul 29 and his first for MIL Aug 6. His 39.8 Hard% over 415 BBE was the 45th highest of 517 pitchers with 100+ BF. Drafted at NFBC ADP rank 402, he finished 1082nd of 1472 in the TDK LABS 5x5 value rank, 680 spots below, and 174th of 236 starting pitchers. The TDK LABS card had him quietly stabilizing in mid-May despite a volatile profile, then by early Sep noted he had been cleared to work back on a shortened rest schedule, and by late Sep read his recent outings as rougher ones that ended early even as the matchup looked soft and the underlying indicators still held up.